A while ago, I went on a date with an African-American woman who is an attorney. We were introduced by a mutual friend who thought we would be perfect for one another given an interest in law and neo-feminism. Before our date we had a few telephone conversations in which she commented “You really don’t have a Philly accent.” I shrugged it off as I have been told by many people that I don’t have a Philly/East Coast accent (whatever the hell that’s supposed to mean). We met for dinner at my favorite Indian restaurant, conversation flowed naturally, she inquired about my interest and points of view and I did the same. The next day she texts me to tell me that she enjoyed dinner. I told her that we can do it again if she is interested. Her response: “That’s cool BUT I don’t think we’re a good match. You’re not Black enough for me…” What do you mean I’m not Black enough? Is my complexion not dark enough? My hair not kinky enough? What is Black enough?
“You talk like a White girl…”
I’ve always talked this way, it is what it is
“You’re very comfortable around White people…”
And I should not be because?
“You don’t dress like other Black women…”
Do you mean I don’t dress like a video ho’ or some Ghetto Hot Mess?
“You don’t listen to Rap music…”
Nor do I listen to Heavy Metal or Twangy Country Western
“You don’t use slang or Ebonics…”
I was raised and taught to use proper English, weren’t you?
This experience is not uncommon. At the end of the day, I am going to do and be me. I am not going to resort to the status qou behavior just to gain acceptance from a subset of people who believe I should conduct myself in a manner which I have been taught is inappropriate. So what if I talk, dress, act “White”, it has gotten me this far so I must being doing something right.
I am reading this and shaking my head. This world needs to get it together. I would probably hang up on or walk away from anyone who said that to me. I too have beem told I "talk white" or I can't be from Philly because of how I act, speak, and dress and its stupid. I am surprised that a well educated black female could show such ignorance. Black women cant seem to catch a break. Either we are to much or not enough... I saw screw her and everyone who thinks like her. Sounds like a bad case of field ~igger syndrome to me. Im over it.
ReplyDeleteI still don't know what "Black enough" means or encompasses. Like is there some level of Blackness one must achieve in order to pass in the African-American community? Even the media sees this trend in the African-American community as I have seen this very issue highligted on a few sitcoms such as Girlfriends and Half & Half. The message I am getting is that if you don't act like the stereotypical African-American who lives in the hood then you are disowning your heritage. I'm sorry but I am not comfortable with the hood mentality or way of life. And if that makes me a "White Girl" then so be it...
ReplyDeleteOoooooohhhhhh.....I have been told I talk like a white girl on many occasions. When I was younger it happened alot and I was really hurt and offended by it. Now, I honestly don't associate with people who would think this of me. Black women do have it hard. Damned if you do and damned if you don't. At the end of the day I will do and live how I feel comfortable and what makes me happy.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you both - you're damned if you, you're damned if you don't. I don't want to be some stereotype. I believe a lot of these statements are born out of jealousy. Just because I talk, dress, act a certain way doesn't mean I think I am better than anyone who doesn't. I think this is also another form of the Colorism argument.
ReplyDelete